Skip to content
Submittal

Submittal tracking spreadsheet vs software for contractors and when Excel stops paying

A spreadsheet is a fine submittal tracker until the job has more than about 50 packages, more than one person editing, or reviewers who need to see status without calling you. After that, the hours spent building the list, chasing stamps and fixing broken filters cost more than a per project submittal tool. The deciding question is not features. It is who builds the list from the spec, and what happens when the same file is open in two places.

Assistant project manager highlighting rows on a printed spreadsheet submittal log in a site office

Submittal tracking in Excel compared with submittal software

Here is the honest side by side for a typical commercial job with a 400 to 800 page project manual.

QuestionSpreadsheetSubmittal software
Who builds the list from the specYou, by reading every sectionThe tool reads the spec and lists each required item with its paragraph
Time to first complete logTwo to four working days on a large manualMinutes to generate, then a review pass
Who sees statusWhoever you email the file toEveryone invited, in the same view
Reviewer stamps and due datesTyped in by handReview route with standard stamps and overdue flags
Version controlFile names like log_v7_FINALOne live register with a history
CostSoftware you already pay forFrom 24 USD a month per project billed yearly on Submittal
Where it winsZero setup, any format, total controlSpeed, traceability, fewer missed items

If your job has 30 submittals and one person, stay in Excel. Our own submittal log template page shows the columns that matter.

Five signs your submittal spreadsheet has stopped working

These are the failures we hear about most from project engineers, in the order they usually appear.

  1. 1The list is incomplete. A spreadsheet only contains what someone remembered to type. The items buried in Part 1 of a section, such as mockups, qualification statements, test reports and warranty forms, are the ones missing at closeout.
  2. 2Two people edit different copies. One copy lives on the superintendent's laptop, one in the shared drive, and the architect has a PDF from last Thursday.
  3. 3You cannot answer who is holding it. A column called Status says Submitted, but not to whom, since when, or how many days the reviewer has had it.
  4. 4Resubmittals lose their history. Revision R1, R2 and R3 end up as overwritten cells, so you cannot show the architect what changed. Our article on what revise and resubmit means explains why that history matters.
  5. 5Closeout becomes a hunt. O&M manuals, warranties and attic stock were never on the list, so the last two weeks of the job are spent finding them.

Any two of these is a signal. All five on one job, and the spreadsheet is costing you more than it saves.

What a spreadsheet costs in labor on one job

Take a mid size building with 300 required submittal items. This is an illustration with stated assumptions, not a measured study. Use your own hours and rate.

TaskHours in ExcelHours with a tool that builds from the spec
Read the spec and build the list20 to 302 to 4 (review pass)
Assign trades, dates and numbering43
Weekly status chasing and reports over 6 months52 (2 hours a week)26 (1 hour a week)
Closeout checking83
Total84 to 9434 to 36

At a loaded cost of 60 to 90 USD an hour for a project engineer, the difference of about 50 hours is roughly 3,000 to 4,500 USD on this one job. A year of Submittal Starter for one project is 288 USD. Even if the time savings are half of this, the tool pays for itself in the first month. The pricing side is compared in detail in our submittal software pricing article.

The step a spreadsheet cannot do

The biggest cost in the table is the first line, and a spreadsheet does not reduce it at all. It is only a place to put the answer. The work of finding the answer is reading MasterFormat sections and pulling out every submittal paragraph. A tool that does this is described in how to build a submittal log from the spec book, and the construction specification software page shows the same step in the product. Many project engineers keep exporting the result to Excel for the owner meeting, which is fine. The export is Excel, CSV or PDF at any point.

When a spreadsheet is still the right answer

Be honest about the cases where software does not pay.

  • Small repair and service jobs with a short, stable list
  • A single person running the job, with no outside reviewers who need to see status
  • A GC that requires all subs to use its own platform, in which case you submit there regardless
  • Trial periods where you want to compare the tool against your spreadsheet on one real spec section first

Even then, a specialty sub running several jobs for different GCs often keeps a personal register across all of them. If that is you, the best submittal software for subcontractors comparison covers the options. A small contractor juggling submittals and bids may also want help getting the word out, and a tool such as an AI marketer that builds a 30 day plan from your website can take some of that off a busy owner.

How to move a spreadsheet log into software without losing history

You do not have to abandon the file on day one.

  1. 1Run the tool on one spec section from your current job and compare its list with your spreadsheet. Note every item it found that you did not have.
  2. 2Start the tool on the next job, not the middle of this one, unless the log is already a mess.
  3. 3Keep the export. Excel, CSV and PDF exports mean the owner and the architect can still receive the format they want.
  4. 4Bring the sub and the reviewer in. Trade contractors and reviewers you invite are free on Submittal, so the whole team shares one view.

The Submittal pricing page lists every plan limit. For the Excel columns themselves, see the submittal register guide and for tracking views the submittal tracking software page. For public guidance on submittal procedures, the AIA publishes the contract framework most reviews follow, at aia.org.

Frequently asked questions

Is Excel good enough for tracking submittals?

For a small job with one editor and fewer than about 50 packages, yes. It breaks when the list must be built from a large spec, several people edit it, or reviewers need status without calling. At that point a per project tool saves more labor than it costs.

What is the best way to track construction submittals?

Keep one live register where every required item has a spec reference, a responsible party, a due date and a review status. That can be a disciplined spreadsheet on a small job, or a tool that builds the list from the spec on larger ones.

How much does submittal tracking software cost compared with Excel?

Excel costs nothing extra but costs labor. Submittal starts at 24 USD a month billed yearly for one active project, 288 USD a year, with subs and reviewers free. Per user tools can cost several thousand dollars a year for a small team.

Can I import my Excel submittal log into software?

You can run the tool on your spec and compare its list with your spreadsheet, then keep exporting to Excel, CSV or PDF for reports. For the best result start on a new job, so history is clean from the first row.

How long does it take to build a submittal log by hand?

On a project manual of 400 to 800 pages, two to four working days is common for a careful project engineer. A tool that reads the spec shortens it to a review pass, which is the main time saving over a spreadsheet.

Build your first submittal log